
The film I am looking at is Mamma Mia (Phyllida Lloyd, 2008) for my case study. I am firstly going to look at reviews by both critics and fans.
There is a review of Mamma Mia in the September 2008 issue of Sight and Sound magazine. The review is good saying that it will "leave you dancing (in the best sense of the word) out of the cinema."
There are reviews on the website imdb.com.
Two of them are newsgroup reviews.One of them is by Tom Elce, who gave the film a scathing review. After having just watched The Dark Knight he said he was sujected to a "A poorly choreographed movie musical-cum-tribute to ABBA helmed by a director whose previous body of work is contained entirely in the theatre, the film is an ineptly staged genre film to begin with". He says that the storyline was flimsey and that the actora acted like idiots. The other review was by Homer Yen who made his opinion short and sweet "Sharp songs, flat story."
The other reviews on the website are external reviews. there are lots. A few include, Black Sheep Review by Joseph Belanger (bad review), Cine Visiones by Miguel Canes (good review) and DVD Talk (good review). IMDB has also put on it's website "user comments" which are both negative and positive.
The Guardian newspaper gave the film a OK review. The writer says that it has lots of charm but it lacks cynicism.
The Times says that it is wonderful, sharp and hilarious.